James River Church Scandal: Controversy, Leadership Changes, and Departure from Assemblies of God

The Sword-Swallower Incident: A Tipping Point

Last year, James River Church, located in Springfield, Missouri, found itself at the center of public scrutiny after hosting a men’s conference featuring a shirtless sword-swallower who also performed as a pole dancer at gay nightclubs. The event drew strong condemnation from disgraced pastor Mark Driscoll, who labeled the performance as embodying a "Jezebel spirit." This accusation prompted James River’s Lead Pastor, John Lindell, to publicly confront Driscoll, a move that many consider a significant moment in the church’s decline.

Leadership Struggles and Member Exodus

The fallout from the controversial conference had lasting ramifications. The Roys Report (TRR) has uncovered a series of troubling reports from both former and current church members concerning deceptive bylaws changes, unsettling expulsions, and questionable staff firings. Once a prominent church within the Assemblies of God (AG), Lindell’s abrupt decision to withdraw from the denomination is cited as a crucial moment in the church’s ongoing challenges.

Declining Attendance

James River Church now operates four campuses and claims a congregation of approximately 16,000 weekly attendees. However, numerous former members report a significant drop in attendance, with some campuses resembling "ghost towns."

Social Media Fallout: The Case of Rahela Petian

For many, the sword-swallower controversy spurred deeper issues. Rahela Petian, a long-time church member, was expelled from the church after posting a Facebook status criticizing Lindell’s leadership. The church summoned her for a meeting, where she was accused of causing "disunity." Despite pleading her case, she was barred from attending services, which greatly affected her family, particularly on the emotionally charged Mother’s Day holiday.

Security Measures on Mother’s Day

On the Sunday before Mother’s Day, Petian was confronted by an overwhelming security presence at the church and escorted off the property, a humiliating experience that not only affected her but also distressed her children, who were left stranded outside.

Staff Turmoil: Craig Biernbaum’s Dismissal

Craig Biernbaum, a former facilities coordinator at James River, expressed concerns about Lindell’s portrayal of events involving Driscoll. His attempts to voice these concerns led to his dismissal after a questionable meeting with church leadership. Biernbaum alleges that he was pressured to conform to a narrative that he felt misrepresented the truth.

Departure from Assemblies of God: What Went Wrong?

The decision to sever ties with the Assemblies of God made headlines, with Lindell citing "detrimental" circumstances. However, his statement raised questions when the AG’s leadership dismissed Lindell’s ministerial credentials soon after the split, highlighting concerns about accountability.

Questionable Board Decisions

Lindell claimed a unanimous vote by the church’s board to leave the AG, but sources have revealed discrepancies, including the resignation of one board member over this issue. Legal expertise suggests that the necessary member vote for disaffiliation was likely overlooked.

The 2019 Meeting: A Shift in Governance

In June 2019, James River Church held a significant meeting to change its nonprofit status. Under the pretext of a necessary bureaucratic shift, the church altered its articles of incorporation, stripping members of essential voting rights and complicating future denominational ties.

Allegations of Transparency

Critics argue that these changes reflect a troubling trend of avoiding accountability among church leaders, echoing other scandals in large congregations.

Conclusion: A Church in Crisis

James River Church’s recent controversies signal deeper issues within its governance and leadership practices. The implications of these events raise important questions about accountability, transparency, and the faith community’s future in the Wake of such drastic changes.

---

In my assessment, the situation at James River Church exemplifies significant challenges faced by modern congregations amidst evolving societal values and internal governance struggles. The experiences of its members and the institutional decisions reflect a complex interplay between leadership aspirations and community engagement, which require careful examination and reflection.